HARARE – Justice Maxwell Takuva sitting at the High Court in Harare has ordered President Mnangagwa to make public the Justice Uchena report which reveals how land barons corruptly sold urban State land between 2005 and 2017, thereby prejudicing Government of US$2,97 billion in potential revenue.
The ruling made last week follows an application by opposition Member of Parliament for Harare East, Allan Norman Markham for the release of the report on the Commission of Inquiry into the matter of the sale of State land in and around urban areas since 2005. Markham was represented by Alec Muchadehama of Mbizo, Muchadehama and Makoni Legal Practitioners and President Mnangagwa and the Attorney General who were respondents in the case were represented by J. Shumba.
President Mnangagwa appointed the Commission in 2018 and a damning report detailing how land barons abused State land in all the 10 provinces was produced and findings presented to the President in 2019. The President had since not made the document public.
Many current senior and past Government Ministers and Politburo members appeared before the Commission.
Markham who is the opposition MP for Harare East argued in his application that failure by Mnangagwa to release the report violates the public’s constitutional right to access information held by the State as guaranteed under Section 62 (1) of the Constitution as well as the founding principles of transparency, justice, accountability and responsiveness enshrined in section 3 (2)(g).
Mnangagwa opposed the application and argued that the report contain unproven allegations and if published this may result in law suits against Government. The defense also argued that the law does not compel the Commission to publish the report. However, Mnangagwa also said that there are several members of the public who requested information from the report and they were furnished with it.
Markham said he had since 2019 persistently sought the publication of the report through Parliamentary questions, petitions and formal correspondence both to the President and the relevant Minister, all of which went unanswered.
In making his argument, Muchadehama cited the case of Philips v Nova Scotia, a Canadian Supreme Court case where Cory J held that; “one of the primary functions of public inquiries is fact finding. They are often convened in the wake of public shock, horror, disillusionment, or scepticism in order to uncover the truth….. In terms of public questioning, stress and concern they provide the means for the Canadians to be apprised to the conditions pertaining to a worrisome community problem.”
In his ruling, the Judge said that failure to publicise the Commission report violates the rights of the public to access information held by the State. He said the omission is not consistent with values of the nation as enshrined in Section 3 (2) (g) of the Constitution of Zimbabwe and therefore ordered President Mnangagwa to release the report within 90 days of the date of the judgment.
Gov ordered to release Uchena Report in 90 days


