A Catholic who preferred anonymity has written a letter to the Zimbabwe Catholic Bishops’ Conference (ZCBC) following the Church’s acceptance of a donation of US$250 000 plus a US$75 000 vehicle from controversial tenderpreneur, Wicknell Chivayo. The author of the letter sums up the matter by saying; if the Church no longer unsettles power, if she no longer explains itself to the faithful, if she draws no line between gospel mission and political patronage…
History will judge this moment. So will the faithful. So will God.
Citing Canon Law the letter raises various concerns ie;
- That the church’s proximity to power and acceptance of high value gifts has compromised it and the author likened ZCBC to any other affiliate for ED ie; vendors 4ED, matsotsi 4ED, teachers 4ED. The source also questioned the construction of Our Lady of Perpetual Help School by the army after funds for the project were raised from poor Catholics.
- The loss of credibility; that the acceptance of privileges offered by civil authority erodes credibility. The church is gaining material support but losing moral distance.
- Accountability to the faithful; the Canon Law requires administrators of ecclesiastical goods to render accounts to the faithful. Silence is not prudence, it is failure of stewardship.
- That bishops and priests seeking security in power, prestige and material assurance rather than vulnerability of the gospel have become common yet Popes have taught against this including Pope Francis
- Church’s authority must not come from access to power but from freedom from it (Romero and the measure of fidelity)
- The poor and optics of indifference:
“In rural Zimbabwe, the faithful struggle to survive economic collapse. They fundraise while hungry. They walk long distances to Mass. They give from scarcity, not surplus. Against this backdrop, priests are assured accommodation, meals, and transport, and now increasingly benefit from luxuries unimaginable to those they serve. What is administratively justified is pastorally devastating. The optics matter because they reveal alignment. A Church that appears comfortable while her people suffer cannot credibly claim the preferential option for the poor,” reads part of the letter.
Full letter


