His Excellency Cde Dr Emmerson Dambudzo Mnangagwa
President of the Republic of Zimbabwe
Office of the President and Cabinet
Munuhumutapa Building, Samora Machel Ave, Harare, Zimbabwe
RE: LET US NOT UNDERMINE THE INVESTIGATION INVOLVING WICKNELL CHIVHAYO, ZIMBABWE DESERVES TRUTH, TRANSPARENCY AND JUSTICE
Your Excellency,
I write to you as a concerned Zimbabwean who believes that the credibility of our nation, the integrity of our justice system and the confidence of our citizens depend on our willingness to confront difficult questions openly and honestly.
The investigation involving businessman Wicknell Chivhayo presents an important opportunity for Zimbabwe to demonstrate that investigations involving prominent or influential individuals can be conducted independently, professionally and transparently.
Your Excellency, my appeal is, let us not allow any investigation to be sabotaged, compromised, influenced or undermined. Zimbabwe cannot afford another situation in which unanswered questions, public speculation and concerns about institutional transparency overshadow the search for truth.
Zimbabweโs history of unanswered questions, Your Excellency, Zimbabwe has a long and painful history of prominent deaths that have generated controversy, public suspicion and questions that continue to be raised decades later.
These include:
Herbert Wiltshire Chitepo, who died in a car-bomb explosion in Lusaka, Zambia, in March 1975.
General Josiah Magama Tongogara, who died in a road accident in Mozambique in December 1979.
General Solomon Mujuru, who died in a house fire in August 2011.
Douglas Tawanda Munatsi, the businessman who died in an apartment fire in Harare in November 2021.
These deaths occurred under different circumstances and were subject to different forms of investigation and official explanation. Some were investigated through formal inquiries or inquests, while others have continued to generate public debate.
I do not suggest that these deaths were necessarily the result of criminal activity or that official findings should automatically be rejected. However, the continuing public questions surrounding them demonstrate the importance of credible investigations and clear communication.
For many Zimbabweans, the problem is not simply the loss of prominent individuals. It is the perception that the public has not always received sufficiently detailed explanations to resolve lingering doubts.
A nation cannot build lasting confidence in its institutions when important questions remain unanswered in the minds of its citizens.
Let This Investigation Set a New Standard
Your Excellency, Zimbabwe has an opportunity to establish a higher standard of transparency and accountability.
Where an investigation concerns a death, the public must have confidence that the circumstances have been examined thoroughly, that relevant evidence has been preserved and that any required inquest is conducted independently.
Your Excellency, Zimbabwe is working to attract international investment, rebuild confidence in its institutions and strengthen its reputation within the international community. The credibility of our investigative and judicial institutions is an important part of that effort.
Investors, international partners and ordinary citizens need confidence that the rule of law applies equally, regardless of an individualโs wealth, political connections or social standing.
Transparency should not be regarded as an attack on Government. Properly conducted investigations can protect innocent individuals from unfounded allegations while ensuring that wrongdoing, where established by evidence, is addressed through the law. Justice must not only be done, the public must be able to understand how the truth was established.
A respectful appeal to your excellency. Mr President, I respectfully appeal to your office to support the independence of the relevant investigative and judicial institutions and to ensure that no person, regardless of position or influence, improperly interferes with their work.
Zimbabweans should not have to wait another 20, 30 or 40 years to continue debating what happened in a case that could have been thoroughly and transparently investigated.
Let us establish a standard under which every death investigation is treated with the seriousness it deserves, every family is entitled to answers and every individual involved is afforded the protection of due process.
Your Excellency, this is not about political affiliation, personal relationships or the reputation of any particular individual. It is about the truth. It is about justice. It is about the credibility of Zimbabwe.
Let this be an opportunity to strengthen public confidence in the institutions entrusted with establishing the facts.
Yours respectfully,
Jacob Kudzayi Mutisi


