DUMISANI KUFARUWENGA
SUBJECT MATTER:
Enforceability, at law, of an agreement between friends in the following circumstances;
FACTS
- friend A’s wife fails to conceive
-friend A approaches friend B to help friend A’s wife conceive through friend B having sexual intercourse with friend A’s wife.
-Friend B agrees
-A fixed fee of money payable to friend B by friend A is agreed on for accomplishing the task aforesaid, namely to impregnate friend A’s wife - Friend A pays the agreed amount to friend B
-Friend B, in compliance with the terms of the agreement between himself and friend A, and with friend A and friend A’s wife’s consent, performs 77 acts of sexual intercourse on friend As wife - Friend B fails to impregnate friend A’s wife after the 77 attempts aforesaid.
-lt is discovered after the 77 attempts that friend B is sterile, and is incapable of fathering a child
-Friend A takes friend B to Court, claiming a refund of the amount friend A paid to friend B, on account of friend B’s failure to impregnate friend A’s wife.
THE LAW
Under Zimbabwean law, an agreement, whether written or oral, is enforceable at law.
Such agreements are called contracts.
If someone agrees to do something, and later fails to carry out what he or she agreed to carry out, that person is in breach of contract and can be taken to Court for failure to fulfill the terms of the contract.
But purely social arrangemens do not fall under the umbrella of contracts which are enforceable at law.
If, for example, l promise to attend my daughter’s birthday party and fail to do so because I met an old friend along the way and we got drunk, my daughter cannot take me to Court for failure to attend her birthday party, because this is a purely social arrangement.
APPLYING THE LAW TO THE FACTS
The agreement between friend A and friend B was NOT merely a social arrangement.
It was a commercial transaction where; - an amount was agrreed on and paid.
-the task for which the amount was paid was defined with sufficient certainty, which was to impregnate friend A’s wife
-there was a serious and deliberate intention to be contractually bound.
Even if the transaction was between friends, it had features of an enforceable contract as opposed to a social arrangement.
Friend A is therefore entitled to take friend B to Court for breach of contract
At law, friend A has two choices;
He is entitled to ask the Court to compel friend B to fulfill the contract, that is, to make friend A’s wife pregnant; (specific performance)
OR Ask the Court to cancel the agreement on account of friend B’s failure to fulfill it, and claim his refund.
From the facts, friend A has adopted the later, that is, he is claiming a refund.
WILL FRIEND A SUCCEED IN COURT?
No he won’t.
In our law, impossibility of performance is a complete defence.
Friend B is sterile . It was and is an impossibility for him to impregnate friend A’s wife.
In other words, if it was not, at the time they concluded the agreement, within the contemplation of both of them that friend B was sterile, the contract was void ab initio (from the beginning) because it was incapable of performance.
A Court of Law cannot recognise or enforce it.
Got it?
CONCLUSION
So friend A looses all the way.


