MASVINGO – Zanu PF activist Patience Mapfumo has lost with costs her bid to overturn the results of Rujeko Primary School Development Committee (SDC) election results held on February 28, 2026. Justice Sunsleey Zisengwe, sitting at Masvingo High Court ordered Mapfumo to pay legal costs on an ordinary scale for two defendants that she was suing, Masvingo City Council Housing and Social Services Director Simbarashe Mandishona and Rujeko Primary School head.Phineas Muchati.
Justice Zisengwe said Mapfumo was perilously close to paying the defendants on a punitive scale (higher scale) had she herself sued Rujeko Primary School with costs.
Mapfumo who was the outgoing SDC chairperson contested for re-election but got a thumping. She complained that the elections were not free and fair while the other side always accused her and her Zanu PF compatriots, in particular Ward 10 Councillor Sengerai Manyanga of bussing party supporters to influence SDC elections around the city.
Mapfumo was the SDC chairperson for five years and Police attended elections almost all the time because of the rowdiness mainly caused by vendors hired from Mucheke Bus Rank.
Justice Zisengwe threw Mapfumo’s application over a non-joinder (failure to include a necessary party in a lawsuit) before the case could be argued. Mapfumo neglected to cite members of the new SDC committee as respondents as they are also affected by the court’s judgment. Justice Zisengwe said he was lenient with Mapfumo because she didn’t have a lawyer until the day of the hearing and she wasn’t seeking to get costs had she won the case.
Mandishona, Muchati and Provincial Education Director (PED) Shylatte Mhike were respondents in the matter. Mhike didn’t file an opposing affidavit while Mandishona and Muchati were represented by Jackson Mupoperi of Saratoga Makausi Law Chambers.
Rujeko Primary is a Masvingo City run school.
Mupoperi raised a preliminary point in law (a discrete legal argument raised at the outset of a dispute which can have a case dismissed). He argued that the application was fatally defective because Mapfumo didn’t include members of the new SDC committee and should be thrown out.
He said that he notified Mapfumo in his heads of arguments that her application was defective and she didn’t act on the warning.
Mapfumo was represented by Maddock Chiwasa of Dube-Banda Nzarayapenga and Partners. Chiwasa told the court that his client was until Monday morning a self-actor who was not well versed with the law.id that Mapfumo’s head of arguments show that she has some legal knowledge or sought help from a bogus lawyer.
Mapfumo said she refused to accept results of the elections because some elected SDC members were ineligible, school head Phineas Muchati summoned Police to harass voters and teachers were allowed to vote and some voters were locked out of the school.
“Application is defective on account of material non-joiner and is therefore struck off the roll. Applicant to meet second and third respondents costs on an ordinary scale,” reads Justice Zisengwe’s judgment.
Former Rujeko SDC chair loses case with costs


