MASVINGO – Masvingo Regional Magistrate Innocent Bepura has yesterday dismissed an application for discharge by Masvingo Provincial Education Director Shylatte Mhike at the close of the State case.
Mhike, Masvingo Provincial Education Director Liniah Chinoda and Chivi District Schools Inspector Evershine Ndongwe’s lawyers, Takunda Chikwati of Matutu and Mureri legal practitioners and Yolander Chandata of H. Tafa and Associates had applied for the discharge of the clients, arguing that the State had failed to establish a prima facie case which means that the evidence led in court could barely lead to a conviction and therefore the case be thrown out.
However, Bepura said there were grounds to put the accused on their defence because it is common cause there was a verification process event carried out in Chivi and that members who attended the process were supposed to be paid. It is also not in dispute that Mhike and Chinoda did not attend.
The magistrate said what is in dispute is whether the two claimed money from the program. Magistrate Bepura said that there are two witnesses, Tapiwa Mapindani (Chivi District Education Accountant) and Dzingai Njera (Provincial Education Administration Officer) who said the two accused persons were actually paid.
The magistrate also said that the two accused need to answer on the question of the conclusion of the handwriting expert on signatures appended to the claim forms in question although the defence raised questions over some dates.
He said that it would be premature for the case to end that stage and therefore set the date for the defence case for March 26, 2026.
The State is led by Ruvimbo Makoni.
“The accused persons appeared before this court facing a charge, the main charge of contravening section 174 of the Criminal Law Codification and Reform Chapter 9:23, that is criminal abuse of duty as public officers. That is to say or it being alleged that the accused persons being public officers intentionally acted contrary to their duties by claiming $600 for travelling and subsistence allowance for attending a Chivi district account verification program which was carried out between October 1 to 10, 2023, when in fact they never attended the said program, thereby showing favour to themselves,” said magistrate Bepura in his ruling.
The defence had applied for the discharge arguing that the evidence submitted in court did not warrant for them to be put on their defence. They argued that the evidence did not establish the essential elements for the offense or for criminal abuse of office.
They raised five issues and these included whether BSPZ is or is not a public entity. They raised the question of whether the accused received the money or not and whether they authored and submitted the Travel and Subsistence claim forms.


