CATHERINE MUROMBEDZI
HEALTH CORRESPONDENT
In a landmark decision, the Harare High Court has ruled that Zimbabwe’s abortion law is unconstitutional, specifically regarding access to abortion for minors.The law denying access to legal abortion for children below the age of 18 and married women who are victims of marital rape was ruled as unconstitutional.BackgroundZimbabwe’s Termination of Pregnancy Act has been restrictive, only allowing abortions under limited circumstances. However, Justice Maxwell Takuva’s ruling declares Section 2(1) of the Act invalid, recognising that denying abortion access to vulnerable individuals violates their dignity and constitutional rights.The Termination of Pregnancy Act only permits abortion in three situations: where the continuation of the pregnancy endangers the life of the woman, where there is a serious risk that the child to be born will suffer from a permanent physical or mental defect.
Thirdly, where the child was conceived through rape other than rape within a marriage.He ruled: “In my view, the dignity of adolescent children who are impregnated, the dignity of married women who are raped is adversely affected by the provisions of s 2(1) of the Act. The Zimbabwe constitution protects the right of every person to the entitlement of inherent dignity in their private and public life and the right to have that dignity respected and protected. The right to dignity is foundational and has been equated with the right to life.“Section 2 of the Act falls away immediately as a consequence of Constitutional Court judgements. Firstly, once the Constitutional Court had outlawed child marriages as it did in the Mudzuri case and once the court outlawed and raised the age of sexual consent to 18 years as it did in the Diana Eunise Kamwenda case, it means that sexual intercourse with a minor is unlawful.
“Consequently, this type of unlawful intercourse should be included in the definition of ‘unlawful intercourse’ in section 2(1). In the same vein, once the legislature has outlawed marital rape as it did with the amendments to the law, it follows then that section (2)(1) should be set aside.”Justice Takuva’s ruling, which would provide access to safe and legal abortion for abused children below 18 years of age, must be confirmed by the Constitutional Court.The judge said section 81 of the Zimbabwe Constitution provides that every child has a right to be protected from sexual exploitation.He added: “In view of this, any sex with a minor is therefore unconstitutional and therefore any pregnancy arising from such sex has to be treated as unlawful intercourse for the purpose of section 2(1) of the Act.“Once it is accepted that the age of sexual consent consistent with section 81 of the Constitution is 18, it becomes clear that any sexual act with a minor and indeed any pregnancy arising thereto, is unlawful and illegal.
“Subjecting children to child pregnancies without a right to safe abortion is abuse and torture in violation of section 53 of the Constitution of Zimbabwe.”The judge said the challenge of children delivering babies was a “major human rights issue.”“According to Dr Nawal Nour, ‘the problem with children delivering children is that the young mothers are at a significantly higher risk than older women for debilitating illness and even death. Compared with women above 20 years of age, girls 10 – 14 years of age are 5 – 7 times more likely to die from child birth, and girls 15 – 19 years of age are twice as likely…’“In Zimbabwe, it is well accepted that teenage pregnancies are largely as a result of poverty.
Poverty is at the epi-centre of causing early child marriages because girls from indigent backgrounds are more vulnerable to pregnancies and child marriages.“It becomes a vicious cycle in that the young girls who get pregnant and often in poor families are then forced to produce young children in a sea of poverty, and the cycle begins again. Simply put, teenage pregnancies foster poverty and cyclical reproduction of poverty as girls who marry young or are pregnant in an uneducated environment with few opportunities continue reproducing the same.”Impact on Reproductive RightsThis decision is crucial in Zimbabwe, where teenage pregnancies often result from poverty and child marriages. Human rights lawyer Tendai Biti welcomed the ruling, stating it would protect the rights of vulnerable individuals.
Biti, who argued the matter on behalf of Women in Law in Southern Africa (WLSA) and Talent Forget, said the ruling would “protect the girl child”.“Children were dying by the thousands in illegal and unsafe abortions. This small victory hopefully closes the chapter of child mothers in Zimbabwe,” said Biti.Next StepsA senior Harare lawyer, Sheillah Kanyangarara, welcomed the ruling.”This is a welcome ruling. It highlights the need for Parliament to consistently review laws in order to ensure that the rights of women are respected. Of course, the ruling is subject to confirmation by the Constitutional Court as per the requirements of the Constitution,” said Sheillah Kanyangarara, Lecturer in Law.”Interestingly, the court did not address the question of marital rape and consequent pregnancy. The Applicant had urged the court to rule that the law ought to be amended to read that ‘Unlawful intercourse means rape including marital rape, sexual intercourse with a minor and sexual intercourse within a prohibited relationship other than sexual intercourse.
Instead, the honourable court ruled that “Section 2(1) of the Termination of Pregnancy Act [Chapter 15:10] be and is here by declared unconstitutional and invalid.”The honourable court did not deal with the question of constitutionality of pregnancy and rape within marriage. Rape within marriage is unlawful in terms of the Criminal Code. At the same time, the Termination of Pregnancy Act prohibits termination of pregnancy that may occur as a result of rape within marriage,” Kanyangarara pointed out.”The blanket ruling that section 2 of the Termination of Pregnancy Act is unconstitutional skirted the issue of unlawfulness of pregnancy that occurs as a result of marital rape.
A ruling that pregnancy that occurs within marriage, but as a result of marital rape could open floodgates for abortion for every unplanned pregnancy in marriage, under the guise of marital rape,” Kanyangarara said.”Meanwhile, what is required is for the Ministry of Health and Child Care to amend policy to authorise health practitioners to counsel patients on the option to terminate pregnancy in children under 18,” said Kanyangarara.The Ministry of Home Affairs should also prioritise the investigations of all reports of rape. There have been cases where the investigations took too long, resulting in the victim giving birth.In 2007, the Supreme Court made a groundbreaking ruling, allowing a woman from Chegutu who became pregnant after being raped to claim damages from the State.
The woman, who was seeking US$10,000 in damages, was raped by robbers in 2006 and failed to access emergency contraception and abortion due to delays by police and court officials.According to the Supreme Court Judge Bharat Patel, it was clear that the woman did not want to become pregnant, and the State’s failure to prevent the pregnancy caused her mental anguish. The woman eventually gave birth to a son and sued the State for maintenance in 2007.This ruling is significant, as it highlights the need for the State to take responsibility for having failed the victim.The process of obtaining a legal abortion is often cumbersome from police investigations, a court order and approval from medical professionals.
Feedback: [email protected]


https://farmaciabesurica.com/# comprare medicinali online senza ricetta
farmacie senza ricetta online: Scegli Farmacia – farmacia online Italia
Truly no matter if someone doesn’t understand then its up to other users
that they will assist, so here it happens. xnxx